How I lost⁠—and

found⁠—my path.

When I was outgrowing my old life, I was desperate for stories from people going through the same thing: people experiencing the same disorientation, uncertainty, and fear when standing on the edge of change.

Below, I share my story without sparing any details. No matter the transition you’re navigating⁠—be it in work, love, or life⁠⁠—I hope you find resonance here.

1. The Climb

I was a nerdy and precocious kid. From a young age, I faced a lot of bullying⁠⁠, and I never really felt like I belonged.

But even when I didn’t have any friends on the soccer team—even when I was the last one in class to find a project partner—achievement was there for me as my refuge.

When I got a good grade, or pleased a teacher with the correct answer, I felt the momentary rush of being seen⁠. Of mattering.

As I got older, and my culture insisted that fulfillment came from striving for success, I didn’t question it.

I got straight A’s.
I chased gold stars.
I climbed every ladder I could find.

And for a long time, it led me exactly where I wanted to go.

In the late 2010s, I became a certified coach and built a business that helped people recover from people-pleasing. When my videos went viral in 2020, my coaching practice took off⁠ overnight⁠. 

2. The Ache

I was thrilled to be able to reach and help more people. But in truth, that moment marked my slow descent into years of overwork.

I lost full days monitoring social media.

Hours after hosting a successful event, I’d stand bleary-eyed at my whiteboard, clock ticking past midnight as I planned my next offering.

My connections to friends, family, and community were afterthought⁠s; I only made time for them when it was convenient (which wasn’t often).

Now, don’t get me wrong. I genuinely loved helping my clients. Watching a recovering people-pleaser say their first empowered “no” never ceased to give me proud goosebumps. (It still does!)

Coaching felt like my calling⁠⁠. But like many who start businesses from a place of true passion and service, over time, my energies were co-opted by the pressures to grow, scale, and maintain a public brand.

Professionally, I was burning out.
Personally, my life was narrowing⁠.

As the years passed, I got a six-figure book deal with Simon & Schuster, features in the New York Times, and speaking opportunities around the world⁠.

But the highs were brief, and the goalpost kept moving.

Once in a long while, as if released from a spell, I’d glimpse the sun sparkling on the Puget Sound. I’d feel an ache in my chest: If this is living the dream, then why does it feel so hollow?

Anxiously, I tried to suppress the thought that I’ve now heard from many of my clients: “I got everything I was supposed to want, but it didn’t fulfill me like I thought it would.”

For a while, I ignored the empty feeling and kept pushing. I was flourishing by the standards of conventional success, and it would be foolish—ungrateful, even!⁠—to change course.

Like many on the cusp of transition, I was in denial. I wasn’t ready to admit that the path to happiness I’d been chasing was a mirage⁠—until the wakeup call that changed everything.

3. The Wake-Up Call

My wake-up call was a series of events—some gradual, some sudden—that made me question everything I’d ever been taught about fulfillment.

First, I fell in love with an incredible man. His life had been full of challenges: losses, life-changing injuries, depression. 

Despite these hardships⁠—or perhaps because of them⁠—he’d found purpose in helping others as best he could. He spent his days caring for the critically injured at a public hospital, his nights taking care of his children.

His struggles had broken open his heart and left a profound compassion⁠ in their wake.

Loving him softened my heart in a million ways. After a lifetime of messaging to “hustle,” he showed me to what a life propelled by (non-people-pleasing) devotion to something beyond the individualistic self⁠ could look like.

Time passed. There was news of climate change. Attacks on trans rights. The genocide in Gaza. Social safety nets being dismantled.

My social media content about self-advocacy started to feel… off. I would write about prioritizing oneself—about setting boundaries around over-giving⁠—and wonder where healthy altruism and caring for the collective fit in. 

Self-advocacy wasn’t incompatible with collective thinking⁠—but as my values shifted, I felt called to elevate different conversations.

What about the individual sacrifices we make to be part of stronger communities? What about risking personal discomfort⁠ to stand up for what’s right?

And what about the issues I stayed silent about⁠ to avoid jeopardizing my success?

I didn't speak up about political issues because I didn't want to risk losing followers, income, or the algorithm’s favor⁠. I was protecting my success, a choice I had every right to make⁠—but that choice came at the cost of my integrity. And it weighed heavy like a stone.

And then⁠—just as my debut book STOP People Pleasing was months from being published⁠⁠—a series of emergencies made the tension between my inner truth and outer life impossible to ignore.

My sister had a life-threatening health scare.

My partner needed a serious heart surgery⁠.

And days later, I received a call that a beloved family member had died of cancer. 

Standing there with the phone pressed to my ear in the bright December sunlight, I felt like I was moving through water⁠. Life’s fleeting nature hit me with full force, followed by a montage of regrets:

Family vacations I’d spent glued to my laptop. Phone calls from loved ones I’d never returned. Late-night emails that had distracted me from my partner. Days, weeks, lost to social media.

In that moment, I finally accepted what my heart had been trying to tell me.

I’d been fed a lie of where real fulfillment came from⁠—and I’d sacrificed my connection to myself, my loved ones, and my community for success’ false promises.

I had tied my meaning and identity to a pursuit I didn’t believe in anymore.


I didn’t know what was next. I just knew I couldn’t go on like this.

It was terrible timing to reach this conclusion. My debut book⁠ was months from coming out, and it would bring more exposure and opportunities than I’d ever had before.

But I was learning that we don’t get to choose the moments that transform us. We only get to decide whether we heed their wakeup call.

So as soon as my book came out, I used the advance to support me as I minimized my public presence, kept a tiny roster of clients, and stepped back to discover who I was⁠⁠—what life was⁠—beyond individualistic striving.

4. The Wilderness

The following year felt like wandering through the wilderness, complete with messiness, uncertainty, and full-blown identity crisis.

I spent the first few months in acute burnout recovery, doing the bare minimum: sleeping, eating, tending to long-neglected doctor’s appointments⁠. With nothing work-related to plan, the days blurred, and I felt like a shell of a person.

From the couch in my sweatpants, I opened Instagram to see my colleagues hustling harder, landing second book deals, and tripling their social media followings. I sat uncomfortably in the stillness⁠—my heart racing, chest tight⁠—thinking of all the momentum I was squandering.

Without success as my guiding light, I was like someone who had lost their faith, stumbling through the dark without a North Star⁠.

I journaled a lot during this time⁠, and confusion kept surfacing in the pages. I didn't want to stop coaching. I adored helping people, and I treasured the creativity of running my own business.

During career transitions, some of us outgrow what we do; others outgrow how we do it. I was in the second camp.

Ultimately, I’d allowed the heart-led aspects of my work to become co-opted by striving. And the greatest sacrifice of that striving had been deep, meaningful connection.

Deep connection, and contribution, to the people I loved. To the causes I believed in. To my community, locally and globally.

On the surface, this transition was about “my job." But deep down, it was about success being dethroned as my meaning, identity, and the orienting value I shaped the arc of my life around.

And I wanted connection to take its place.

I both craved this, and feared this. Success had kept me safe⁠—and made me feel seen⁠—⁠ for so long.

As often happens during transition, the part of me that found safety in my old ways got louder as I challenged it:

You’re so ungrateful to risk throwing your success away like this!
Other coaches hustle twice as hard and feel fine.
You’re being too sensitive.
Too weak!

It was like being caught in a painful tug of war between who I’d been, and who I was becoming.

I had compassion for my fear, but it was trying to drag me back to the one place I knew I couldn’t return. 

5. The New Way

It was time to test my hypothesis that centering connection would offer a more meaningful life than centering success ever had.

As the fog of burnout lifted, I began pouring my time into the relationships and communities that made me feel most alive.

After years of letting my friendships wilt, I tended to them like I would a garden: proactively, intentionally, and with great care. I made a point to check in on my friends in hard times and good ones, celebrating birthdays, engagements, and album releases.

I helped weed gardens.
Moved furniture.
Gave airport rides. 

Finally, I returned the family calls I’d been neglecting. I set up monthly Zoom chats with a cousin; visited my aunt in Florida; and spent longer stretches with my parents in New Jersey. 

As the months passed, I began to feel less like a satellite in space, and more like a thread in a vast web of connection and care. It felt more fulfilling—more meaningful—than any of my successes ever had.

Hoping to anchor myself during this time of change, I joined a meditation community. Over the course of months, sitting silently and watching my mind, I began to develop a compassionate appreciation for me⁠: this small being trying her best, breathing.

I started volunteering at the meditation center.
Got coffee with elderly folks in my community.
Participated in my local mutual aid group.

My mental health slowly returned, and my creativity with it. This time, instead of exploiting my creativity entirely for work, I let it roam free: guitar, book clubs, themed events.

Life began to feel rich. I began to feel whole.

My resentment at the long year of struggle slowly gave way to gratitude for the chance to open my eyes to what really mattered.

After a year in the trenches of transition, I finally felt clear enough⁠—grounded enough⁠ —to return to my business in a new way.

New boundaries around my time.
More accessible pricing structures.
More focus on authenticity, collective care, and community-building.
The willingness to lose income, followers, and opportunities in order to maintain my integrity and live by my convictions.

And most importantly⁠⁠—a new topic. My heart was being pulled in a new direction⁠⁠: transition and meaning-shifts.

Throughout my transition, I kept thinking about how grounding it would have been to have someone who knew my story walking beside me.

Someone who understood the unfamiliar terrain of transition; who knew its phases. Who helped me normalize my disorientation, messiness, and identity crisis not as problems, but as vital parts of the journey.

Someone who offered frameworks. Structure. Who helped me explore my changing meaning, purpose, and values so I could build a reliable inner compass to chart my course.

Someone who held space for my fear. Who helped me root down in courage. Who helped me strategize my next chapter.

I wanted to become that trail guide for others.

So I spent months deep in research, exploring how to bridge my coaching expertise and training with this new topic: transitions.

I studied the things that actually give people a sense of meaning. I learned how traditional success keeps us stuck on the hedonic treadmill⁠: constantly striving, but never arriving.

I listened to hundreds of stories of people who had trusted their gut when they’d outgrown their old lives⁠—and who had found real fulfillment on the other side. And I researched the science of life transitions, learning how they shift not only our external worlds, but our identities, values, and beliefs.

I’d felt alone in my lostness, but the truth was, many had walked this path before me.

Life transitions⁠ were a known quantity with relatively predictable stages; common sets of shifting beliefs; and cyclical seasons of shedding, lostness, and becoming, each rich with invitations to grow.

6. The Return

Today, I no longer sacrifice connection to chase success. I create far less “content,” host fewer events than ever before, and when I close my computer on Friday, it stays closed till Monday.

I use my platform to speak authentically, and to stand up for the causes that I believe in⁠—not just the messages that will go viral or attract followers.

As a result of these shifts, I’ve absolutely lost some income. I’ve lost some followers. And I’ve lost some opportunities.

And it’s nothing compared to what I’ve gained.

With connection as my North Star, how I spend my time⁠⁠—and how meaningful that time feels⁠—has shifted radically⁠.

I nurture a rich social circle and feel more connected to my community than I ever have before. Stillness is a common companions—not a fleeting visitor⁠—and I feel present for the hundreds of small moments that make life ordinary and transcendent at once.

Of course, I still live in a culture that champions individualistic success⁠. I’m not immune to passing comparisons between me and my peers, or a moment of disappointment when a social media post performs poorly⁠.

But now, these fleeting feelings last mere moments instead of days. I unhook from them quickly by reminding myself what really matters⁠.

My transition made one thing abundantly clear: It can be terrifying to step off of the old path and leap into the wilderness of the unknown.

But when the tension between our inner truth and outer lives becomes impossible to ignore, our vitality and happiness depend on us taking that leap⁠.

Today,
I guide people through the alchemical process of life transition. When who you’ve been no longer fits who you’re becoming, I walk beside you through the wilderness of change⁠⁠—helping you journey from doubt and uncertainty to clarity, self-trust, and a new chapter that is radically alive.

In my personal journey, this has meant centering connection after years of striving⁠—but for others, the shift looks different.

For some, it’s coming home to themselves after losing their identity in a relationship that’s ended. For others, it’s walking away from prestigious careers to pursue their creativity⁠—reclaiming spiritual callings that have been buried by worldly demands⁠—or rediscovering who they are after years of selfless parenthood. 

The particulars differ, but the throughline is the same: letting go of old identities to enter the wilderness of transition—and to slowly find the path toward what feels deeply meaningful and alive.

Certified by the International Coaching Federation and Erickson Coaching International, I’ve coached hundreds through the wilds of transition in their work, relationships, beliefs, and beyond.

My coaching approach combines practicality of solution-focused coaching with the emotional richness of depth coaching: perfect for those who want to make tangible change while diving into the big questions of meaning, purpose, and identity.

You can learn more about my coaching approach and methodology here.

Your heart-led life is waiting for you. I hope you will join me there.

Hailey Magee